NCOC Featured Discussion

The Opportunity Cost of Civic Engagement

The cost of community involvement during a recession

August 12, 2009
by flickr user clementine gallot,
home page image by flickr user simonk
In these tough economic times, it seems as if everyone is cutting something from their monthly budgets. Summer vacation, going out for dinner, volunteering at the local food bank—wait… what was that last one?

Recent studies have shown interesting and varied levels of correlation between community involvement around the United States and its direct connection to the economy and unemployment. The recently-released Volunteering in America report by the Corporation for National and Community Service found an increase in the number of people volunteering between September 2007 and September 2008, just when the economy was beginning its initial descent.

Historically, however, a significantly depressed economy means a decline in civic engagement—the Great Depression saw a recession of civic activity as individuals scaled back their involvement in order to take care of their families during challenging times. This trend is supported by other recent articles, including one by UCLA sociology professor Jennie Brand find that when people are less certain about their jobs, or are in the unfortunate situation of being laid off, they are much less inclined to volunteer their time at various social, community, and civic groups.

The UCLA study notes “In the first study to look at the long-term impact of job displacement on social participation, we found that workers who had experienced just one involuntary disruption in their employment status were 35 percent less likely to be involved in their communities than their counterparts who had never experienced a job loss due to layoff, downsizing or restructuring, or a business closing or relocating.”

With evidence suggesting an incredibly strong bond between employment and civic engagement, it brings one to wonder about the reasons behind this trend of seclusion from community involvement. Would it be rational to assume that displaced workers should volunteer more of their time in hopes of networking for future employment? Or does the trend make sense that without a pay check and a feeling of security, it is hard to find motivation to become civically involved?

Which begs the question: In challenging economic times, what are the opportunity costs associated with being civically engaged? Can we afford not to be?

The 2009 America’s Civic Health Index: Civic Health in Hard Times, being released by NCoC later this month, explores the relationship between economic vitality and civic health, and discusses the ways Americans are engaging to get through these tough times. At the 2009 National Conference on Citizenship, we will discuss these findings and challenge the ways investments of time, talent, and treasure are measured in a way that recognizes their civic return and their true impact in communities.
Rate This Page
No one has yet rated this article.

 

2 Comments
By Stephen Buckley at 3:15 PM on Aug 13th, 2009
Judging from the recent upsurge of "civic engagement" at town-hall meetings during the current Congressional recess, I would say that the poor state of our economy, and the attendant uncertainties for citizens, may actually be THE biggest factor causing that upsurge.

Now, if you are defining "civic engagement" to only mean citizen participation in "good works" (i.e., volunteering), then that would not include the public's increased participation at town-hall meetings and the like.

If that is the case, then you need to explain if your use of the term "civic engagement" includes one or both types of public participation.

That distinction is important, because it could be that one part (volunteerism) is going down at the very same time that the other (political participation) is going up.

And so, to have a better discussion, there needs to be clarification on your "civic engagement" terminology.

sincerely,
Stephen Buckley
http://www.UStransparency.com
By Kristen Cambell at 12:00 PM on Aug 16th, 2009
Hi, Stephen,
Thank you for raising this critically important point. For NCoC, civic engagement is more broad than volunteering and we measure and discuss multi-faceted elements of engagement, including volunteering, but also looking more broadly to activities such as expressing political views, participating in public meetings, trusting others, and working with others to fix or improve something. So, a variety of actions occur in civic participation, which contributes to our overall civic health and state of civic engagement in our society.
Name:  (optional)
Email:  (optional)
  Comment:
 
  Enter the text you see in the image below.

 
Can't wait to see you! RT @ktgirl1 Just registered for #NCoC on September 17. Outrageous list of industry leaders participating. Are you? About 7 hours ago reply
RT @ADPaascu Become a partner with Rock the Vote and use their cool, new online tool for the midterm election! http://fb.me/xeJkkshl About 7 hours ago reply
Congrats to our friends at CIRCLE on the launch of their new website-- a truly valuable resource for the civic sector: www.civicyouth.org About 15 hours ago reply